Pacific Media Watch

12 November 2011

PNG: Exploitative mining does not lead to quality life, shows development index

Hero image
Papua New Guinean children standing in mine tailings at Porgera. Photo: Mining Injustice
PMW ID
7715

PORT MORESBY (PNG Mine Watch / Pacific Media Watch): Strong economic growth and exploitative  large-scale extractive industries do not lead to a better quality of life for people in Papua New Guinea, according to the latest Human Development Index.

The index places PNG 153rd out of 187 countries in the world.

Countries like Palau and Tonga which have not suffered from exploitative large-scale logging, mining and land grabbing rank much higher at 49th and 90th respectively and are rated as high human development countries.

In the medium development category are Samoa (99), Fiji (100), FSM (116), Kiribati (122) and Vanuatu (125).

PNG and the Solomon Islands(142) are the only Pacific countries ranked in the lowest human development category.

Papua New Guinea has had six-years of stellar economic growth but this has only served to benefit a small-elite and the foreign owners of PNG's logging, mining and oil and gas companies.

It is time for us to reject the failed unrestrained capitalism that is being forced on us by our former colonial masters and return instead to the National Goals in our Constitution to guide our futures.

PNG ranks poorly in HDI survey
Resources-rich Papua New Guinea has been ranked 153 out of 187 countries surveyed on the Human Development Index, falling below most of its smaller South Pacific island neighbours.

This ranking places PNG in the last of four rankings from very high human development to low human development.

Of the nine Pacific nations included in the survey, Melanesian neighbour the Solomon Islands shares this category but is 11 places higher at 142.

Tiny Palau, which was included in the ranking only this year, and Tonga ranked 49 and 90 respectively. They are the only island nations that are part of the high human development ranked countries.

Australia is second and New Zealand is fifth on the ranking.

The 2011 report, themed Sustainability and equity: A better future for all, argues that environmental sustainability could be most fairly and effectively achieved by addressing health, education, income and gender disparities together with the need for global action on energy production and ecosystem protection.

The HDI is a yardstick that focuses on the human elements of development, combining indicators of health and education with the more traditional economic indicators.

It normally gives important insights that can be used to identify key development needs.
It said in PNG’s case, despite strident economic growth in the past six years, the area of human development had largely been ignored.

Pacific Island countries have varied levels of human development.

Most of the Pacific Island countries appear in the “medium human development” category.

These include by rank Samoa (99), Fiji (100), FSM (116), Kiribati (122) and Vanuatu (125).

Three countries in the Pacific have higher than average life expectancy than other small island development states.

These are Palau 64, Tonga 63 and Fiji 62 years respectively.
 
(cc) Creative Commons

PNG Mine Watch

Mining Injustice Solidarity Network
 

Pacific Media Watch

PMC's media monitoring service

Pacific Media Watch is compiled for the Pacific Media Centre as a regional media freedom and educational resource by a network of journalists, students, stringers and commentators. (cc) Creative Commons

Terms